Nickel Boys Movie Review: A Haunting, Visceral Adaptation That Redefines Cinematic Storytelling
RaMell Ross’s adaptation of The Nickel Boys delivers a raw, immersive experience that rejects traditional storytelling for something more profound.
Some Films Tell Stories. Nickel Boys Makes You Live Them
Few films transcend the screen and embed themselves into the viewer’s psyche like Nickel Boys, RaMell Ross’s bold and unflinching adaptation of Colson Whitehead’s Pulitzer Prize-winning novel. Unlike traditional historical dramas that follow a structured narrative arc, Nickel Boys is a film that breathes, lingers, and confronts its audience with a stark, immersive portrayal of institutional cruelty and racial injustice in 1960s America.
Ross, best known for his experimental documentary Hale County This Morning, This Evening, brings the same poetic and observational lens to this adaptation. Instead of simply recounting events, he crafts a cinematic experience that oscillates between moments of quiet devastation and suffocating tension, making the audience feel the weight of the story rather than just witnessing it.
A Story Rooted in Injustice
At the heart of Nickel Boys is Elwood Curtis (Ethan Herisse), an idealistic African American teenager who clings to Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.’s vision of justice and equality. Raised by his loving but weary grandmother (Aunjanue Ellis-Taylor), Elwood is a bookish young man with dreams of education and upward mobility. However, a cruel twist of fate lands him at the Nickel Academy, a reform school modeled after the infamous real-life Dozier School for Boys. Here, the institution’s facade of discipline masks a brutal system of racial abuse and dehumanization.
Elwood quickly learns that his belief in righteousness offers little protection. Opposing his idealism is Turner (Brandon Wilson), a street-smart survivor who understands that morality has no place in a world governed by systemic cruelty. Their friendship is the film’s emotional core—two boys tethered together by circumstance yet divided by their outlook on survival. Through their evolving dynamic, Ross poses a chilling question: Is it safer to hope, or to simply endure?
Style as Substance: A Bold Cinematic Approach
Ross refuses to follow conventional storytelling rules. Instead, he immerses the audience in the atmosphere of the Nickel Academy through evocative cinematography, disorienting soundscapes, and a fragmented, memory-like narrative structure. The film’s pacing is deliberate, sometimes excruciatingly so, but this choice serves its purpose. Each lingering frame and moment of silence forces the audience to sit with the discomfort of injustice, making the film’s impact all the more profound.
The cinematography, with its careful framing and painterly compositions, transforms every shot into a work of art. Ross, whose background in photography informs his visual style, crafts images that feel like artifacts of a painful history, more felt than seen. The film’s use of sound—or its absence—is just as meticulous. Silence becomes a character, amplifying the horror of the unseen and the echoes of past traumas.
Performances That Linger
Ethan Herisse delivers a hauntingly restrained performance as Elwood, embodying the quiet hope and gradual disillusionment of a boy forced to navigate a world that refuses to see his humanity. His portrayal is not about grand speeches or overt expressions of suffering; instead, his pain is internalized—visible in his posture, his gaze, and the small shifts in his demeanor as his optimism erodes.
Brandon Wilson as Turner provides the perfect counterbalance. His pragmatic worldview is delivered with raw authenticity, making his internal conflicts just as compelling as Elwood’s. Their chemistry is understated but palpable, adding depth to their friendship and the choices they make.
Aunjanue Ellis-Taylor, in limited screen time, delivers a performance that resonates long after her scenes end. As Elwood’s grandmother, she carries the weight of generations, her every word laced with quiet sorrow and unspoken fears. Meanwhile, Hamish Linklater’s portrayal of the school’s coldly bureaucratic superintendent is chilling in its restraint, proving that the most terrifying villains often wear the mask of civility.
A Film That Refuses to Offer Easy Resolutions
What sets Nickel Boys apart from other historical dramas is its refusal to offer conventional catharsis. There are no grand moments of triumph, no neatly packaged resolutions. The film lingers in its audience’s mind long after the credits roll, refusing to let them escape the weight of its truths.
For some, this will be a difficult watch. The slow pacing, the abstract storytelling, and the refusal to conform to mainstream cinematic expectations may alienate casual viewers. But for those willing to engage with its raw, uncompromising vision, Nickel Boys is an unforgettable and necessary piece of cinema.
Final Verdict: A Must-See, But Not an Easy Watch
Nickel Boys is not entertainment in the traditional sense. It is a film that challenges, unsettles, and forces introspection. It doesn’t just tell a story; it demands that you bear witness. Ross has crafted a cinematic experience that is as artistically bold as it is emotionally devastating. Few films manage to balance style and substance so effectively, but here, style is the substance.
Rating: 4.5/5
Some films are meant to be watched; others are meant to be experienced. Nickel Boys is firmly in the latter category. It is a harrowing, necessary film that refuses to make history palatable and, in doing so, ensures that its message will not be forgotten.
(Disclaimer: This article is based on publicly available information and industry reports. While every effort has been made to ensure accuracy, details are subject to change. Readers are encouraged to refer to official sources for the latest updates.)
Also Read: Gene Hackman and Betsy Arakawa Found Dead at 95 and 63: A Hollywood Legend’s Mysterious Farewell